Demand for a separate law had first come to the floor in 2006. The Doctors’ Protection Act was passed in 2010, but is plagued by weak implementation.In the wake of kinesiology tape resident doctors going on mass leave Maharashtra chief minister Devendra Fadnavis has said in the House there would be total protection for doctors. There already exits, however, a law to protect all medical professionals from any kind of violence in the state. The Maharashtra Legislature had passed it way back in 2010, but its weak implementation is a persistent problem. Demand for a separate law had first come to the floor in 2006.
There were incidents in Mumbai as well as other parts of the state where patients’ relatives attacked doctors. To prevent this, a delegation of doctors had met then home minister R.R. Patil. In response, the state government initiated an ordinance on March 30, 2009. It reads, “For the prevention of the violence against Medicare service persons and prevention of the damage or loss of medical property.” The ordinance was passed as an Act in 2010. This law protects all doctors, nurses, medical students, nursing students, para-medical workers, and other workers who directly or indirectly work under medical institutions.
It also covers damage to property of medical institutions, medical colleges, laboratories, pathologies, mobile medical units and other related properties, which comes under medical service criteria. This Act also defines the nature of violence. It reads, “Any harm, an injury, endangering the life or intimidation, obstruction, hindrance will be prohibited.” Causing physical harm to a medical professional is a punishable offence and offenders face a jail sentence of up to three years and a fine of Rs 50,000 under the Act. The fine varies on the nature of the harm done. However, some doctors feel the law has been proven a failure “In the last three years alone a total of 45 cases have been registered under the Doctors’ Protection Act, but not a single case has reached the final stage,” said Dr Yash Kabra, president of Maharashtra Association of Resident Doctors (MARD).Dr Kabra also demanded an increase in offenders’ prison sentence to seven years.

Talking to The Asian Age, Ms Suchde said, “Firstly, the police denied to investigate into the case then the panel are playing power game. “People are getting more aware and are filing complaints. It gets delayed between the police station and hospitals. As we are not authorised to seek any document or information directly from the accused doctors or medical practitioners, we have to be dependent on police.In 2013, Nandini Suchde, a resident of Colaba filed a complaint at Azad Maidan police station against doctors from Bombay Hospital alleging negligence that led to the death of her mother. In 2011, only 38 cases were referred to the hospital, which rose to 83 in 2014. Lahane said, “In most of the cases, we don’t get detailed information. So, until we get all the required documents, we cant finalise on any case so it remains pending.. But sadly, only 28 cases have been investigated. And till September of 2015, 47 cases have been recorded. This fact has come to light following an RTI query filed by Shreya Nimonkar, a victim of medical negligence. In the past five years, since 2011, total 271 cases have been recorded with the hospital while only 105 cases have been disposed of.
The panel confirmed professional medical negligence and an FIR was registered against the doctors by the police station. As per rules, police referred her case to a team of medical experts at Sir JJ Group of Hospitals for further investigation.In 2013, Nandini Suchde, a resident of Colaba filed a complaint at Azad Maidan police station against doctors from Bombay Hospital alleging negligence that led to the death of her mother.P. But most of the files gather dust at the hospital and patients keep waiting for justice. Explaining the reasons behind files being kept pending, JJ Hospital dean Dr T. She added that when she asked about the total number of verdicts given against hockey tape doctors, the hospital refused to provide it, calling it “classified”. In 2014, total 83 cases of medical negligence were referred to the hospital for medical reference. However, a few months later, the same panel refuted the report and denied medical negligence in the case. When they declared that it was a culpable homicide case, how can they refuse it just after four months ”Like her, files of several patients are sent to the expert panel of JJ Hospital for investigation. But what’s the point if they don’t get justice and the cases remain pending,” said Ms Nimonkar. The query was filed through her ‘Forum for Patients’ Right for Medical Negligence’.”As per the data, the case of alleged medical negligence case is on the rise in the city.

Agitating doctors have deep concerns over alleged privatisation of medical education. Resident doctors from various hospitals like All India Institute of Medical Science (AIIMS), Safdarjung, Ram Manohar Lohia, Lady Hardinge, GTB and Lok Nayak are protesting over the provisions of the NMC Bill. For example, the doctors are uncertain on the concept of NEXT and demolishing NEET-PG."I have appealed doctors to call off the strike so that patients should not get any difficulty in availing healthcare facilities," read another tweet. As we cotton athletic tape are not satisfied, we still put our concern to the health minister over the ambiguity of the NMC bill. The Bill provides that the common final year MBBS exam be known as NEXT which would serve as a licentiate exam for entrance to post-graduate medical courses and as a screening test for foreign medical graduates. "The NMC bill will give undue favours to the private medical colleges/unaided universities by decreasing the percentage of seats under the controlled fee structure from 85 per cent to 50 per cent," doctors said.
I have explained to doctors that NMC bill is one of the biggest reform in the medical education sector which is would a blessing for 130 crore population of the country," he tweeted.Dr Prakash Thakur, President, Resident Doctors Association (RDA) at Safdarjung Hospital, who was in the meeting with the Union Minister, told ANI: "We have been informed by the health minister that there would be no amendment in the NMC bill.‘I have appealed doctors to call off the strike so patients shouldnt get any difficulty in availing healthcare facilities,’ he tweeted.With the doctors strike against the National Medical Commission (NMC) Bill 2019 entering the fourth day on Sunday, Union Health Minister Dr Harsh Vardhan met agitating doctors and urged them to call off their strike.It provides for the repeal of the Indian Medical Council Act 1956.Agitating doctors have deep concerns over alleged privatisation of medical education. I have clarified their doubts and misunderstanding related to NMC bill.
Similarly, they are disagreeing the concept of Community Health Providers (CHP) included in the Bill..Doctors have shown their dissatisfaction over the alleged ambiguity of the NMC bill."Due to the strike, healthcare services have badly been affected and thousands of patients are having a tough time in availing treatment."Today morning, I have met RDA representatives of Safdarjung and AIIMS.Doctors have shown their dissatisfaction over the ambiguity of the Bill. Protest against NMC bill is still on.The All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), Federation of Resident Doctors Association (FORDA) and United Resident Doctors Association (URDA) have been protesting against the NMC bill.Both the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha had passed the NMC Bill which seeks to create National Medical Commission in place of Medical Council of India (MCI) with Vardhan terming it as an "anti-vested interests Bill" which will be remembered as one of the greatest reforms brought by the Narendra Modi government. We have resumed emergency services at Safdarjung hospital.

Soon medical colleges will be put under permanent surveillance. The reason for putting cameras they believe will improve teaching and help check performance of teachers. A slew of cameras will be attached to the MCI so that the video footage generated from the cameras could be viewed as and when required for analysis of classroom performance. So far 50-60 colleges have already got CCTV Wholesale Kinesiology Tape Suppliers installed. With this, the MCI would be able to do live video streaming of classes,” said a senior official in the MCI.Students and teachers will be subjected to permanent surveillance as MCI could use footage to make judgements on lesson standards. The penalty clause will be added once the requirement is notified under the minimum standards required for starting a new medical college or while enhancing the number of medical seats,” added the official.Significantly, the medical regulator also proposes to make installation of cameras in classes mandatory under the “minimum standards” required to open a new medical college. The high-end cameras linked to the servor in MCI will help us do analysis of classroom performance using this as one of the observations systems. The reason for putting cameras they believe will improve teaching and help check performance of teachers.The new rule will soon be notified and once its notified, the MCI proposes to add penalty for those colleges where CCTV cameras are missing. “The idea of video capture is to ensure whether classes are going on properly or not.According to officials, often complaints on inadequate number of lecturers and faculty are received by them and the new method will help expose this menace in both government and private medical colleges. The students and teachers will be subjected to permanent surveillance as MCI could use footage to make judgements on lesson standards.“It will be a mandatory requirement for opening a new medical college but for also those seeking permission for enhacing medical seats. To ensure that teachers are working hard enough, the Medical Council of India (MCI) has issued instructions to both private and government medical colleges to install Closed Circuit Television (CCTV) cameras in the classes.

Dr Anita Pednekar, the hospital’s superintendent, said, “We have a shortage of ward boys and nurses. Ram, 58, a patient, told The Asian Age, “There are many problems, and the ward boy just comes for rounds. Similarly, there is just one ward boy against the sanctioned strength of 11, according to hospital sources. Earlier, there were many patients.” The senior doctor quoted earlier said on condition of anonymity, “The quality of life of these patients are quite poor. This is because they have been abandoned by their families and the hospital has allegedly had no doctor or specialist with five such posts lying vacant since 1997. Amid the manpower Wholesale Kinesiology Tape Suppliers crunch for specialised personnel, three patients with no formal training sit in the outpatient department ward and bandage and dress the wounds of both the in-house and visiting patients in two shifts.
The average age of the 80 persons living here is between 55 and 60, and many suffer from age-related ailments.” “Patients have died here due to various ailments and we have got their treatment done at KEM hospital,” she added. Taxi drivers some times refuse us or demand more money, knowing our state. In the past two months a lot of patients have died.A senior doctor, who served at the hospital as a medical superintendent, said more than 30 patients who resided in the hospital have died since August 2016 due to various ailments. After the detection of any kind of ailment we have to go to KEM as no trained specialist doctor is available. For the rest, these patients have to be dependent on social workers and NGOs. Now due to lack of proper treatments, the deaths have increased. Only food and shelter is provided.The BMC- run Acworth Municipal Hospital for Leprosy, the only hospital of its kind in the city, houses 80 persons that have been cured of the disease, who have been forced to care for themselves and d A ward at Acworth Municipal Hospital for Leprosy The BMC- run Acworth Municipal Hospital for Leprosy, the only hospital of its kind in the city, houses 80 persons that have been cured of the disease, who have been forced to care for themselves and dress each other’s wounds. The ward boys who retired have not been replaced with fresh recruits. Similarly, we need to hire doctors and nurses.The facility, however, has a medical officer who performs only administrative functions